- Props.cash Newsletter
- Posts
- The Curious Case of Donovan Mitchell
The Curious Case of Donovan Mitchell
Plus: SGA, the Jets' Mark Scheifele and the MLB Head-to-Head Data Sheet

Cleveland is on the brink of elimination, needing a win to avoid a stunning second-round exit in just five games at the hands of the Pacers. They’ll need a big night from Donovan Mitchell to keep their season alive. Meanwhile, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander has had back-to-back quiet performances on the road—but as the series returns to Oklahoma City, one key data point suggests a bounce-back could be coming.
In the NHL, the Jets haven’t won a playoff road game since Game 1 against Vegas in 2023—losing eight straight away from home. Can they finally snap the streak and even the series? If so, it might come down to one player rising to the moment.
And as always, we’ve got our daily MLB head-to-head sheet at the bottom.
Let’s dive in.
NBA
The Cavs, and Donovan Mitchell
Cleveland lost Game 4 in the first half—down 80–39 at the break, and while they cut the final margin to 20, the damage was already done. Now, Mitchell and the Cavs are one loss away from a second-round exit in spectacularly bad fashion. But there’s a glimmer of hope: in the two elimination games he’s played as a Cavalier, Donovan Mitchell has delivered—he’s shown up when it matters most.
April 26th, 2023 vs the NYK: played 44 minutes, went 28/7/5, 11/26 FG, 3/12 3PT
May 5th, 2024 vs Orlando: played 45 minutes, went 39/9/5, 11/27 FGA, 2/8 3PT
So far in the series, Mitchell is averaging 34/5/4.5, but because of an ankle injury suffered while warming up for the second half of game 4, he only played 20 minutes. In the other three, he averaged 35.6 minutes per game. In the three games where he played 33+ minutes, he averaged 41/6/6.
Although Mitchell left with that ankle injury, he was at shootaround this morning, moving pretty well:
Donovan Mitchell is active at shootaround this morning. #Cavs
— Camryn Justice (@camijustice)
3:05 PM • May 13, 2025
He’s listed as questionable, but he’s likely to play, and if he plays, we’ll hopefully see him return to some of the big minutes he played in games 1, 2, and 3.
Mitchell, 27.5 Points
When Mitchell plays 36+ this season, he’s averaging 29.8 points per game.

Mitchell when he plays 36 or more minutes
In those games, he’s averaging 23 field goal attempts. This season, attempting 23 or more shots, he’s averaging 33.6 points per game.

Mitchell when he attempts 23 or more shots
Minutes are the key for Mitchell, tonight.
Find out why 1M+ professionals read Superhuman AI daily.
In 2 years you will be working for AI
Or an AI will be working for you
Here's how you can future-proof yourself:
Join the Superhuman AI newsletter – read by 1M+ people at top companies
Master AI tools, tutorials, and news in just 3 minutes a day
Become 10X more productive using AI
Join 1,000,000+ pros at companies like Google, Meta, and Amazon that are using AI to get ahead.
SGA, Averages
In the first two games of the series at home, SGA scored 33 & 34 points, averaging 19.5 field goal attempts and a 65.5 field goal percentage. And then the series shifted to Denver, where SGA scored 18 & 25 points, averaging 20.5 field goal attempts, and a 37% field goal percentage.
Let’s assume we see a bit of a leveling off for SGA, where his attempts stay around 20, and his field goal percentage comes in a little closer to his season average (51.6%) but he still gets that home-court boost. This season, when his field goal percentage is between 52 and 56, SGA is averaging 34.6 points.

SGA’s chart when shooting between 52 and 56% from the field, where he averages 34.6 PPG
Stanley Cup Playoffs
The Jets Need Schiefele
Schiefele had two points in the first two games of the series, a goal and an assist, and contributed 10 shots on goal. In game three in Dallas, Schiefele had zero points with zero shots on goal, with just one shot attempt. In his two games in the first round on the road, Schiefele had just 3 shot attempts with 2 shots on goal and zero points. He needs to find a way to get more involved on the road - and he’s done it this season outside of the playoffs.
He averaged 3.6 shot attempts, 2.1 shots on goal, 0.9 points, and had a goal in 12 of 44 road games this season. This season on the road, the Jets won 26 games, and Schiefele had a point in 21 of those wins.

Schiefele on the road this season, when the Jets win
MLB Head-to-Head Daily Sheet

Head-to-head MLB data for May 13th